March 29, 2017

Pelvic Floor Reconstruction Without Uterine Removal

A safe, effective option for many women of reproductive age

19-OBG-1143

It is not necessary to remove the uterus in order to surgically manage uterine prolapse with an apical suspension procedure. It’s just how the procedure has always been taught, says Cleveland Clinic urogynecologic surgeon Marie Fidela Paraiso, MD.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

“It’s become dogma. You don’t have to remove the uterus if the patient wants to keep it and there is no gynecologic pathology to require its removal,” she says, adding that “some people would argue the uterus is an innocent bystander.”

Dr. Paraiso has performed uterine-preservation pelvic floor reconstruction procedures since the mid- to late-90s. Now, as Head of Cleveland Clinic’s Center for Urogynecology and Reconstructive Pelvic Surgery, she offers the option whenever appropriate.

“Patients who feel strongly about leaving the uterus in place should have that option if it’s safe for them,” she says.

Pros, cons and unknowns

The option to preserve the uterus is particularly important to women of reproductive age. In order to help patients make an informed decision, Dr. Paraiso is frank about pros, cons and unknowns.

“I tell patients most literature involves removing the uterus. The evidence to support keeping it isn’t as robust,” she says.

Advertisement

If the patient has severe uterine prolapse, cystocele and a weak pelvic floor, and is amenable to vaginal mesh placement, Dr. Paraiso is likely to recommend uterine suspension with vaginal mesh. “If the patient hopes to become pregnant in the future, I would use a single mesh and perform the procedure laparoscopically or with robotic assistance,” she adds.

She feels it’s important for patients to know that when a graft is implanted for uterine suspension, hysterectomy later in life may be more difficult. “I also recommend she deliver by Cesarean section,” she says.

Many good options available

Dr. Paraiso performs pelvic floor reconstruction through all available routes: abdominally through an open incision, laparaoscopically with or without robotic assistance and vaginally with mesh suspension or sacrospinous ligament fixation.

A review of all options she conducted in 2008 reinforced there is no gold standard for treating uterine prolapse.

“The optimal procedure for any patient depends on multiple factors, including the presence of specific defects, the patient’s age, comorbidities, activity level, desire for future fertility, history of prior prolapse surgery in other compartments, patient preference, and, of course, the skill and comfort level of the surgeon with the particular procedure. However, all procedures work just as well as when the uterus is removed as when it is not,” she says.

Advertisement

The risk of bowel obstruction from scar tissue is slightly higher with abdominal procedures and lower when the uterine suspension is performed vaginally. A recent study found no difference in the rate of complications whether mesh is placed vaginally or laparoscopically at the time of hysterectomy.

One myth Dr. Paraiso is quick to dispel involves the supposed need to retain the uterus in order to preserve sexual function. “Although some women think their sexual function will be better if they keep their uterus, we have no data to prove or disprove it,” she says.

Related Articles

Paternalism in women's health
July 12, 2023
Commentary: Paternalism in Ob/Gyn Practice

How we create obstacles for sexual, reproductive and menopausal healthcare despite our best intentions

hot flashes
June 12, 2023
A New Family of NK3 Receptor Antagonists Offer Menopausal Symptom Relief

One approved non-hormonal therapy and another on the horizon reduce vasomotor symptoms

Hormone therapy for menopause
June 14, 2022
Hormone Therapy for Prevention Requires a Nuanced Approach

Some post-menopausal patients may benefit from treatment

Linda Bradley, MD
May 11, 2022
Race and Ethnicity Affects Care for Patients with Endometriosis

Study shows higher rates of complications, laparotomies among non-white women

Vaginitis diagnosis
December 17, 2021
The Art and Science of Diagnosing Vaginitis

Proper diagnosis and treatment require a careful mix of patient and clinical considerations

Uterine-preserving surgery
August 30, 2021
Hysteropexy or Hysterectomy for Prolapse Repair: Which Is Safer?

Study uniquely powered to compare adverse effects

Woman placing transdermal testosterone patch on thigh
April 6, 2021
The Role of Androgen Therapy in Female Sexual Health

What is female hypoactive sexual desire disorder and how is it treated?

Woman dispensing hormone replacement gel
April 2, 2021
Prescribing Testosterone and DHEA: The Role of Androgens in Women

Indications and best-practice recommendations for the use of androgen therapy

Ad