Locations:
Search IconSearch
March 15, 2022/Cancer

Allograft Renal Cell Carcinoma From the Donor: Rare, but Possible

Important takeaways from a rare complication

Donor-Derived Renal Cell Carcinoma in a Kidney Allograft: A Case

An unusual case of donor-derived renal cell carcinoma (RCC) in a kidney allograft should serve to raise awareness of the possibility, but not to discourage people from kidney donation.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

RCC in a kidney allograft is rare, with an incidence of 0.19% to 0.5%, and nearly always occurs at least a decade after transplantation. But in one patient seen at Cleveland Clinic, multifocal RCC emerged within six months of transplant and was traced to the donor kidney.

“This is a very rare complication, but such sequelae can happen. It should not discourage people from giving a kidney,” says transplant surgeon Alvin Wee, MD, of Cleveland Clinic’s Glickman Urological and Kidney Institute.

Case details

Dr. Wee and colleagues published a case report in Transplantation Proceedings. The patient was a 68-year-old man with stage V chronic kidney disease secondary to autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease. He received a kidney transplant from a deceased donor. Graft function was excellent; and imaging, protocol biopsy and a cell-free DNA test were all normal.

Then creatinine was noted to be gradually rising at month five. Initially, Dr. Wee and colleagues suspected rejection. Donor-derived cell-free DNA had increased to 1.5% from 0.5% at month six. The transplant ultrasound showed multiple hyperechoic lesions, and further imaging with magnetic resonance imaging revealed diffuse multifocal lesions.

Percutaneous biopsy was unsuccessful; therefore, a laparoscopic-guided biopsy was done and confirmed grade 3 clear-cell RCC. Genetic testing showed that the tumor came from the donor. Allograft nephrectomy was done, and the patient was removed from all immunosuppression.

The donor was a 53-year-old male with a significant history of smoking, yet there was no hint of cancer when the organ first became available. Dr. Wee says, “When we got the kidney, we didn’t see any suspicious lesions, as most RCCs are exophytic. There was no outgrowth or bulging; and a biopsy was also done. All the parameters indicated it was a good organ as reflected from his excellent graft function after transplantation.”

Advertisement

The likely role of immunosuppression

The immunosuppression might have played a role, Dr. Wee says. “If there was a cancer cell, in theory, immunosuppression can cause these cancer cells to grow. Whether there was a cancer cell “hiding,” or was just formed, or mutated leading to the tumor, we won’t really know.”

Consider multifocal RCC in the differential diagnosis

Clinically, the case should raise awareness to include multifocal RCC in the differential diagnosis for multiple lesions in the allograft, and the use of cell-free DNA monitoring can be helpful. At Cleveland Clinic, where 306 kidney and kidney/pancreas transplants were performed in 2021, cell-free DNA is monitored routinely post-transplantation.

Key takeaways

“When the cell-free DNA goes up, you have to be more vigilant watching the graft, as rising creatinine can be a late sign of injury. Cell-free DNA tells you there’s an injury, but not what type. That’s why additional workup may be warranted,” Dr. Wee explains.

The cancer necessitated the removal of the donor kidney, but the patient is doing well on dialysis and will soon be back on the transplant waiting list.

“We stopped the immunosuppression, and he’s fine now. Fortunately, the tumor was only in the kidney and hadn’t spread. We have to wait about two years before considering him again as a transplant candidate,” he says.

Dr. Wee adds, “We have to be vigilant. With our multidisciplinary approach, we were able to detect even the rarest occurrence and save the patient.”

Featured image: Left: Coronal T2-weighted magnetic resonance imaging series demonstrating multiple fluid-filled cysts in the native kidneys with innumerable T2 dark hypoenhancing lesions throughout the kidney allograft. Right: Gross pathology of nephrectomy specimen, renal cell carcinoma, multifocal, clear cell subtype with focal rhabdoid areas, International Society of Urological Pathology grade 4 with invasion into renal vein, renal sinus and perinephric fat, and neoplasm extending to perinephric fat margin of excision.

Advertisement

Used with permission from Elsevier. This figure originally appeared in: Gross MD, Hassanein M, Myles JL, Augustine JJ, Wee A. Donor-Derived Renal Cell Carcinoma in a Kidney Allograft: A Case Report. Transplant Proc. 2022 Jan-Feb;54(1):123-125. doi: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2021.11.017. Epub 2022 Jan 1. PMID: 34980506.

Advertisement

Related Articles

Young patient with cancer
October 25, 2024/Cancer/News & Insight
Multidisciplinary Care Model Supports Young People with Cancer

Integrated program addresses growing need for comprehensive cancer care among adolescents, young adults and adults under 50 with early onset cancers

Hurthle cell carcinoma
October 24, 2024/Cancer/News & Insight
Researchers Uncover Clues to Treating Rare Thyroid Cancer

Studies find mTOR inhibitor may play key role in treating Hurthle cell carcinoma

DNA
October 10, 2024/Cancer/Research
Blocking YES1 Protein Resensitizes Triple-Negative Breast Cancer to Treatment

Obstructing key protein allows for increased treatment uptake for taxane chemotherapy

Plan of care meeting
October 4, 2024/Cancer/Radiation Oncology
Five Years of Parallel Prospective Plan of Care Reviews

Radiation oncology department finds weekly plan of care meetings have multiple benefits

Radiation therapy
October 2, 2024/Cancer
Partial Breast Irradiation Delivered Daily Well Tolerated in Patients with Early-Stage Breast Cancer

Daily five-fraction partial breast irradiation (PBI) shows similar acute and late toxicity as every other day PBI

Ad