July 25, 2023

Composition of PRP May Explain Why Some Injections Work Better Than Others

Patient age and baseline platelet count are considerable influences

Healthcare, doctor and medicine for knee pain injury from accident. Medical help for joint rehabilitation and consulting people. Patient injection for inflammation recovery from surgery in hospital.

Although platelet-rich plasma (PRP) is becoming more common in the treatment of osteoarthritis, soft tissue injuries, tendinopathies and muscle tears, it needs more development and optimization, says Nicolas S. Piuzzi, MD, Director of Cleveland Clinic Adult Reconstruction Research.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

One of the biggest challenges in using PRP is that its composition usually is not known or not reported, he notes.

“If you don’t know the composition of what you injected, it’s hard to assess why it worked or why it failed,” says Dr. Piuzzi.

At the Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires in Argentina, measuring the baseline composition of PRP for each patient is standard of care. As such, Dr. Piuzzi collaborated with Luciano Rossi, MD, PhD, and other researchers at Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires to analyze the center’s patient database, attempting to better understand relationships between demographic factors and PRP. The resulting study was published in Arthroscopy, Sports Medicine, and Rehabilitation.

“The goal of this study was to shed more light on the use of PRP and how it varies by the patient and numerous factors,” says Dr. Piuzzi. “This study is a step toward developing a more consistent, reproducible technique to improve how we provide PRP to patients.”

PRP composition is highly variable

The researchers identified 357 patients treated with 403 PRP injections between January 2019 and December 2021 and evaluated the effects of age, sex, body mass index (BMI) and baseline blood count on PRP composition. They also looked at the variability of PRP composition in patients who received two PRP treatments at separate times.

The study’s key finding was that PRP composition varies considerably.

Advertisement

“It varies between patients and even within the same patient,” says Dr. Piuzzi. “The final concentration of platelets varies significantly depending on when it is prepared. Variation is not always a bad thing, but it’s something to acknowledge, and it’s something that we need to bring into the workflow.”

PRP variability is based on age and baseline platelet count

The greatest influences on final PRP composition were age and baseline platelet count, according to the study. BMI, sex and the remaining components of the baseline blood count (erythrocyte count, hematocrit, hemoglobin level, mean corpuscular volume and leukocyte formula) did not significantly affect final PRP composition.

Patients older than age 60 had the lowest number of platelets. Patients younger than age 40 had the highest number.

“For each decade that a patient aged, there was a decrease of approximately 33,000 platelets,” says Dr. Piuzzi.

Additionally, the PRP platelet count increased almost fourfold for each unit increase in baseline blood platelet count, he notes. Compared with women, men had a lower PRP platelet count, but it wasn’t a significant difference.

PRP composition varies in individuals

“Knowing we have all these variations, even if you had a patient who had a good outcome with PRP at one point, you would need to know the number of platelets and the preparation protocol used so you could attempt to replicate the outcome with a subsequent treatment,” says Dr. Piuzzi.

Advertisement

Of the 357 patients in the study, 34 received a second dose of PRP 15 days after the first injection. These doses showed substantial differences in mean number of platelets, with nearly 40% more platelets in the second treatment (890,018 vs. 1,244,467).

“PRP treatments at different times could yield different results, not only because of the condition being treated but also because of a difference in PRP composition,” says Dr. Piuzzi.

Significance for clinicians

Though the study’s results were what Dr. Piuzzi and his team expected, “it’s nice to put numbers and hard data to it so that it is something we can build on,” he says. “When applying PRP, we need more data-driven approaches, and we need to measure what we’re doing. Otherwise, we’re just going blindly.”

The study’s results have created a benchmark that Dr. Piuzzi hopes can help develop more quality research.

“The next step is to correlate these findings with clinical outcomes to be able to identify thresholds and quality release criteria,” he says.

Related Articles

Healing the world with passion and purpose
April 18, 2023
7 Insights for Orthopaedic Surgeons Building a Research Program

Cleveland Clinic’s Adult Reconstruction Research leaders share what they’ve learned over 16 years

Doctor showing result of radiography to patient
December 22, 2022
Musculoskeletal Disease Causes Most Disability, Healthcare Spending in U.S. but Gets Less than 2% of NIH Research Funds

Cleveland Clinic researchers raise awareness of disparity and call for change

Woman with knee and joint pain at home.
September 15, 2022
Study Quantifies Link Between Mental Health and Outcome of Total Knee Arthroplasty

Patients who score lower than 40 on the VR-12 Mental Component Summary need more care after surgery

Woman hand with pills on, spilling pills out of bottle on dark background.
September 9, 2022
Opioid Study Finds Four Pills Is Enough for Most Patients After Simple Knee Surgery

Reducing prescriptions may help keep unused medication out of the community

A woman with a sore knee holds a chondroprotector tablet and a glass of water, glucosamine and chondroitin sulfate in her hand, copy space
August 12, 2022
NarxCare Score of 300+ Doubles Risk of Longer Hospital Stay, Nonhome Discharge After Total Knee Arthroplasty

Optimize patients for surgery by reducing their overdose risk score

X-ray image of total knee replacement
July 7, 2022
Patient-Reported Data Can Help Predict Outcome of Total Knee Arthroplasty

Study links worse presurgical pain, function and mental health with dissatisfaction one year after surgery

650×450-Prostate-Cancer-Testing-UK-Perspective
May 13, 2021
Can the NarxCare Score Predict Adverse Outcomes in Total Hip Arthroplasty?

Study findings quantify risk for the first time, and what this means for managing care

21-ORI-2046036-CQD-Using-AI-to-Identify-Revision-Surgery-Hero
February 25, 2021
AI and Arthroplasty: New Study Shows 99% Accuracy of Implant Identification

First-of-its-kind study validates AI approach to identify implants using X-rays

Ad