Locations:
Search IconSearch
October 11, 2024/Orthopaedics/Arthritis

Exercise Medicine Helps Patient With ‘Osteobesity’ Avoid Knee Replacement

Patient loses 148 pounds in 18 months, reduces BMI to 26

A 50-year-old white female with hypertension and a body mass index (BMI) of 53.4 presented with progressively worsening bilateral knee pain over three months. She denied any recent injury or change in activity and reported a fairly sedentary lifestyle.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Imaging showed bilateral knee degenerative arthritis, tricompartmental marginal osteophytes and marked medial compartment narrowing with no joint effusion or soft tissue swelling.

Knee osteoarthritis in a patient with obesity
Bilateral knee osteoarthritis in a patient with BMI of 53.4.

Treatment conundrum

While total knee arthroplasty (TKA) is a definitive treatment for knee osteoarthritis, this patient had a 7.41% risk of not being discharged home after surgery due to class 3 obesity. Conventionally, obesity has been linked with higher risk of infection and other complications after TKA, leading many surgeons to consider patients for TKA only if their BMI is 40 or lower.

“What should we advise patients who are at high risk for complication after TKA because of their high BMI, which is partly due to their sedentary lifestyle?” asks Matthew Kampert, DO, a sport and exercise medicine physician at Cleveland Clinic. “I have named their condition ‘osteobesity.’ It’s a downward spiral of worsening joint pain due to high BMI and increasing BMI due to immobilizing joint pain.”

Value of treatment with semaglutide

Anti-obesity medication like semaglutide could be a first-line treatment for this patient’s joint pain, notes Dr. Kampert. While often an effective weight-loss therapy, semaglutide can cost up to $1,365 per month. (Actual price can vary.)

In the STEP 4 study comparing semaglutide with placebo over 68 weeks, researchers reported significant weight loss: 17.3% fewer pounds with semaglutide compared to 2.0% fewer pounds with placebo. However, 52 weeks after stopping use of semaglutide, patients had regained 67.1% of the lost weight, adjusting their total weight loss to only 5.7%.

Advertisement

The value of using semaglutide over those 120 weeks can be represented as 5.7% weight loss for $23,205 (17 months [68 weeks] of semaglutide x $1,365) — or 1% weight loss for $4,071.

Quality of treatment with semaglutide

“We know that patients taking these drugs lose weight, but where is the weight loss coming from?” asks Dr. Kampert.

He points to the STEP 1 trial in which a cohort of patients taking semaglutide had 14.9% weight loss. However, according to DEXA scan, 5.4% of the loss came from lean body mass.

“These participants in the STEP 1 trial also were prescribed a reduced-calorie diet and increased physical activity — 150 minutes per week,” Dr. Kampert says. “But according to American College of Sports Medicine guidelines, adults with obesity may benefit from progression to 250-300 minutes of exercise per week. Some may require progression up to 630 minutes per week. And on at least two days per week, resistance training should be incorporated — something that was not prescribed in the trial. If exercise is medicine, the trial treatment was poor medical management.”

To treat patients for obesity, Dr. Kampert recommends using guideline-based exercise prescriptions and a periodized approach to anti-obesity medication. The medication provides a jump start for people who are conditioned to a sedentary lifestyle and have lower exercise capacity.

“Anti-obesity medication phentermine is less expensive than semaglutide, about $11 per month, although the price can vary,” Dr. Kampert says. “However, it is effective for only about three months at a time. Individuals then need to be off the medication for several months to resensitize to it. Alternating phentermine with semaglutide enables continued weight loss at lower cost.”

Advertisement

Combining medication with exercise prescription

For the patient with obesity and knee osteoarthritis, Dr. Kampert first provided viscosupplementation injections to treat the knee pain. He also prescribed moderate to strenuous exercise more than 300 minutes per week (alternating swimming and land-based cardiorespiratory exercise) along with resistance training five to six days per week.

These lifestyle changes were augmented by sequential anti-obesity medications to help reduce the patient’s appetite. For 12 weeks, the patient took phentermine and lost 24 pounds. For the next 48 weeks, she took semaglutide and lost 97 pounds, followed by another 12 weeks of phentermine, during which she lost 27 more pounds.

Outcome

Over 72 weeks of treatment, the patient lost 148 pounds (50.6%) and reduced her BMI to 26.3. As a result, the patient’s risk of nonhome discharge after TKA decreased from 7.41% to 2.33%.

The total cost of anti-obesity medications was $16,431 — or 1% weight loss for $325 — a fraction of the cost had the patient taken only semaglutide for 72 weeks.

“This profound increase in value and the more significant weight loss compared to other studies are thanks to a more comprehensive approach involving lifestyle interventions,” Dr. Kampert says. “Additionally, the value of care was enhanced by reducing the cost of medication through a periodized approach to anti-obesity medication.”

Although she has been cleared for TKA, the patient has thus far declined surgical intervention and continues to manage her knee pain with viscosupplementation injections every six months and guideline-based exercise. She no longer has hypertension or needs hypertension medication.

Advertisement

X-ray of patient's knees after losing weight
The patient’s knee pain improved after she lost 148 pounds over 18 months thanks to an exercise prescription and a periodized approach to anti-obesity medication.

Writing exercise prescriptions

Dr. Kampert recommends these practices for writing exercise prescriptions.

Physicians who need help writing guideline-based exercise prescriptions can collaborate with exercise professionals, he notes. Exercise professionals can advise on prescriptions, assess patients’ progress and update prescriptions to ensure continued improvement in cardiorespiratory fitness, muscular fitness and body composition.

Advertisement

Related Articles

man with overweight next to icon of a failing heart
Obesity Plus Heart Failure: What Are Safe and Effective Weight Loss Strategies?

New papers review the data and provide guidance on antiobesity medications and other options

Closeup of physician performing bariatric surgery
October 8, 2024/Digestive/Research
Consider Weight Loss Surgery as a Treatment for Chronic Kidney Disease, Obesity

Findings show greater reduction in CKD progression, kidney failure than GLP-1RAs

Physician consulting with patient on weight management
Comparing Obesity-Centric Approach and Usual Care in T2D and Obesity

A weight-management program plus anti-obesity medication performs well

Surgeons performing bariatric surgery
July 2, 2024/Digestive/Research
Bariatric Surgery Improves Cardiovascular Outcomes in Patients with Obstructive Sleep Apnea

Cleveland Clinic study finds that durable weight loss is key to health benefits

woman with milk and lettuce
Empowering Patient Wellness Through Obesity Medicine

Comprehensive approach can make a transformative impact

Knee of patient with obesity
June 11, 2024/Orthopaedics/Hip & Knee
Patients With Obesity Report Faster Improvement After Knee Replacement

More report a clinically meaningful change in function at 90 days compared to patients with lower BMI

Patient weighing herself on scale
Researchers Correlate Psychosocial Characteristics With Weight Recurrence Following Bariatric Surgery

Positive emotions, low impulsivity appear to safeguard against weight gain, other comorbidities

Photo of patient injecting drug into stomach
February 22, 2024/Primary Care/Research
Cleveland Clinic Study Identifies Factors Associated With Long-Term Use of Popular Anti-Obesity Medications

Perserverance may depend on several specifics, including medication type, insurance coverage and medium-term weight loss

Ad