June 3, 2018

Study Suggests Being Selective with Pelvic Lymph Node Dissection Among Patients with Advanced Rectal Cancer


Routine lateral pelvic lymph node dissection for Stage III rectal cancer may not be warranted for all patients. Instead, a selective strategy focusing only on positive node disease following neo-adjuvant treatment could target those patients most likely to benefit, new research presented at Digestive Disease Week 2018 suggests.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Cleveland Clinic researchers studied 166 patients who underwent curative surgery for locally advanced rectal adenocarcinoma. Almost 30 percent had evidence of pelvic lymph node disease on preoperative MRI. The investigators compared their outcomes with the remaining 70 percent who did not have positive disease on imaging.

Before surgery, some patients underwent neoadjuvant chemoradiotherapy. More node-positive patients underwent chemoradiotherapy, 88 percent, compared to 70 percent of the node-negative group.

“Patients who had positive lymph nodes before radiation and chemotherapy had worse outcomes — their local recurrence-free survival was worse than patients who did not have any lymph node involvement in the pelvic area,” says Cleveland Clinic colorectal surgeon and study senior author I. Emre Gorgun, MD.

After a median follow-up of 46 months, a larger proportion of patients in the positive lateral pelvic node disease group experienced local recurrence rates of their cancer, 20 percent, versus 6 percent in the other group. This difference was statistically significant (= 0.005). Overall survival (= 0.46) was comparable and recurrence-free survival rates were significantly worse in the lateral node positive group (P = 0.01) on a Log-rank test.

“Based on that, we are concluding if patients have positive lateral pelvic lymph nodes before and after neo-adjuvant treatment, those patients’ may benefit from lateral pelvic lymph node dissection.”

Lead study author Ipek Sapci, MD, Cleveland Clinic colorectal surgery research fellow, presented the findings Sunday during a Small Bowel and Colorectal Plenary Session at the DDW gastroenterology conference in Washington, D.C.


A closer look at the data

The study population had a mean age of 58 years and 72 percent were male. A total 49 patients had positive iliac or obturator pelvic node disease on preoperative imaging, according to data from a prospectively maintained database and additional chart reviews. Within this group, 17 patients also had a post-neoadjuvant treatment MRI. This imaging revealed a decrease in the size of nodes or resolution of nodal disease among 15 patients.

Optimal management of lateral pelvic nodal disease in locally advanced rectal cancer remains debatable around the world, the authors noted. In Japan, for example, this type of dissection is more common, even among rectal adenocarcinoma patients who do not have evidence of lateral pelvic lymph node involvement, Dr. Gorgun says.

“Japanese surgeons routinely perform lateral pelvic lymph node dissection. However, the data there is questionable,” Dr. Gorgun says. There is no clear evidence that, on ‘all comers,’ that taking out those lymph nodes provides benefit.”

Removing the nodes regardless of imaging evidence could expose some patients to longer surgeries and greater morbidity, he adds. “We are proposing a more selective approach in our dataset.”


Further study warranted

Even though overall survival were not statistically significant, the finding of greater recurrence and worse recurrence-free survival among those with evidence of nodal disease warrants further study, Dr. Gorgun says. “Patients with this type of presentation [positive nodes on MRI] should not be ignored. This is an important aspect of rectal cancer that is often overlooked,” he says.

“These lymph nodes should be removed in the appropriate patients,” Dr. Gorgun explains. “Dissection of lymph nodes in that area is technically demanding; it’s close to vital structures like veins, the iliac artery and nerves. You really need good technical skills and dexterity.”

If a surgeon is not comfortable performing lateral pelvic lymph node dissection in patients with rectal cancer, they can refer them to a center with surgeons with specific expertise in this area. At Cleveland Clinic, for example, he says, “patient volume and ancillary staff like research fellows and personnel who are readily available for us allow us to do studies like this. Additionally, technologies such as robotics facilitates these technically demanding procedures accomplished with ease.”

Related Articles

Impostor phenomenon
February 6, 2024
Recognizing the Impact of Impostor Phenomenon and Microaggressions in Gastroenterology

The importance of raising awareness and taking steps to mitigate these occurrences

Koji Hashimoto, MD, and team
February 2, 2024
Combined Cardiac Surgery and Liver Transplant Is a New Option for Highly Selected Patients

New research indicates feasibility and helps identify which patients could benefit

December 8, 2023
MILU Improves Outcomes Among Critically Ill Patients with Advanced Liver Disease

Standardized and collaborative care improves liver transplantations

November 17, 2023
Younger Patients with Alcohol-Associated Hepatitis Present to the ED More Often, Research Shows

Caregiver collaboration and patient education remain critical

food allergies
October 26, 2023
What Gastroenterologists Need to Know About Managing Food Allergies in Clinical Practice

Beyond recognizing and treating food allergies, GIs also have a responsibility to address common food allergy misconceptions

October 25, 2023
ChatGPT “Pretty Good” at Basic IBS Info, but Misses Details

Important to recognize limitations when it comes to healthcare and research

celiac disease
October 24, 2023
Women’s Health Disorders Found More Frequently Among Individuals With Celiac Disease

Findings reinforce the importance of multidisciplinary care

Miguel Reguiero, MD
October 23, 2023
No Link Between Small Molecule Therapies and Cardiovascular Events in New IBD Study

Underlying inflammation may cause higher rates of CV events