January 4, 2023/Cancer/Research

Invasive Lobular Cancer and Invasive Ductal Cancer Require Different Clinical Management

Patients with ER-positive invasive lobular cancer face worse disease-free survival and overall survival

Dr. Megan Kruse

Under current national treatment guidelines, both invasive lobular cancer (ILC) and invasive ductal cancer (IDC) fall under the same category. Yet patients with ILC have a distinct clinical presentation and outcomes compared to their hormone receptor counterparts. This is further evidence that the two diseases require a distinct approach to clinical management, according to a new study published in the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

As members of the Great Lakes Breast Cancer Consortium, Cleveland Clinic researchers participated in the major retrospective study analyzing data about 33,662 patients with breast cancer treated between 1990 and 2017 at three large clinical centers. The analysis revealed that patients with ILC:

  • Were diagnosed at later stages and had more lymph node involvement
  • Underwent statistically more mastectomies than patients with ER-positive IDC
  • Had survival outcomes that were notably worse than patients with IDC

“Our biggest hope is that this kind of study will shed light on the fact that we should be looking into ILC as a distinct clinical entity,” says Megan L. Kruse, MD, study co-author and a breast oncologist at Taussig Cancer Institute. “This data has energized investigators to look for new diagnosis and treatment strategies. In the next few years, we are hoping to open multiple clinical trials to start to address ILC specific issues, including better staging of patients, better monitoring of their response to treatment and ultimately, testing new treatment approaches.”

ILC diagnosis challenges

Some lobular cancers are difficult to find, even with the latest breast imaging. Patients often have non-specific presentation (symptoms such as skin thickening, puckering/rippling or nipple inversion), and may not have a typical mass like what occurs in ductal carcinoma. “If a patient has breast symptoms, the initial mammogram and ultrasound are negative and there isn’t a clear lump in the breast, a clinician may just watch it,” says Dr. Kruse. “But if clinical symptoms persist, sometimes you need to take a step further with evaluation through a breast MRI.”

“It’s essential when a patient is diagnosed with breast cancer to have their tissue samples read by a pathologist who is familiar with ILC,” advises Dr. Kruse. “This is to ensure that we are best identifying patients who need different evaluation or need be identified for participation in clinical trials.” Unlike IDC metastases, which often manifest as solid tumors in other organs, ILC can spread into the lining of organs like the stomach or intestines. If a patient is having gastrointestinal symptoms like persistent, unexplained nausea, vomiting or abdominal pain, a referral for endoscopy may be warranted in light of an ILC history.


Emerging treatment options

Newer treatment options such as targeted treatments against PIK3CA mutations or novel anti-estrogen therapies may have an advantage over chemotherapy for patients with metastatic ILC. “For patients with earlier stage ILC, however, there are not many newer treatment options, so having clinical trials for this population is really important,” says Dr. Kruse.

One option for some patients with early-stage ILC at high risk of recurrence is a CDK4/6 inhibitor called abemaciclib (Verzenio), which was recently approved by the FDA, as a result of the Monarch E study. When used with hormone therapy, abemaciclib was shown to prolong disease-free survival in patients with hormone-receptor-positive, HER2-negative, high-risk, early stage breast cancer.

“With current early-stage FDA approval of abemaciclib, patients were required to have a high Ki-67 biomarker to be a candidate for the drug, but sometimes patients with ILC have a low Ki-67, even if there is a good deal of lymph node involvement,” says Dr. Kruse. “Thankfully, in the Monarch E study, there was a group of patients who received abemaciclib due to extensive lymph node involvement without having a high Ki-67, so we can use that as justification to get approval of the medication when appropriate.”

Many questions remain

Researchers at Cleveland Clinic are looking to understand myriad factors that may influence patient outcomes. One troubling trend they noted was an increase in the size of lobular cancers over time. In evaluating the study population diagnosed between 1990-2017, they found a constant and steady increase in tumor size over the years. “That’s a trend we weren’t expecting that is worthy of future study,” says Dr. Kruse.


Tumor size is just one of the many unknowns that researchers are looking to better ascertain. They hope to use the data sets acquired by the Great Lakes Breast Cancer Consortium to determine if factors such as body mass index or socioeconomics contribute to different outcomes. The three clinical centers that participated in the study gathered detailed information about other medical conditions patients were diagnosed with. This information may provide clues to help researchers better understand ILC risk factors.

Hear our podcast with Dr. Kruse about managing the differences between ILC and IDC.

Related Articles

Doctors working on MGUS screening study
March 18, 2024/Cancer/Research
Pilot Study Aims for Early Identification of Multiple Myeloma Precursor Among Black Patients

First-of-its-kind research investigates the viability of standard screening to reduce the burden of late-stage cancer diagnoses

Physician with patient
March 6, 2024/Cancer/Research
Targeting Uncontrolled Erythrocytosis in Polycythemia Vera with Rusfertide

Study demonstrates ability to reduce patients’ reliance on phlebotomies to stabilize hematocrit levels

Doctor measuring patient's waist size
February 26, 2024/Cancer/Research
Impact of Obesity on GVHD & Transplant Outcomes in Hematologic Malignancies

Findings highlight an association between obesity and an increased incidence of moderate-severe disease

Physician with patient
February 21, 2024/Cancer/Research
Strategies for Improving Clinical Trial Equity

Cleveland Clinic Cancer Institute takes multi-faceted approach to increasing clinical trial access

How antibody drug conjugates work
February 13, 2024/Cancer/Research
Real-World Use of Trastuzumab Deruxtecan

Key learnings from DESTINY trials

February 1, 2024/Cancer/Research
Possibilities of CRISPR Technology (Podcast)

Gene editing technology offers promise for treating multiple myeloma and other hematologic malignancies, as well as solid tumors

Disparities in multiple myeloma
January 25, 2024/Cancer/Research
Major Study Identifies Global Disparities in Drug Toxicity for Multiple Myeloma Treatment

Study of 401,576 patients reveals differences in cancer burdens as well as overall survival

Dr. Shilpa Gupta
December 27, 2023/Cancer/Research
A New Standard Emerges in Advanced Urothelial Carcinoma After Decades of First-Line Chemotherapy

Enfortumab plus pembrolizumab reduced risk of death by 53% compared with platinum-based chemotherapy