Long-term freedom from seizures and functional outcomes for adults following hemispherectomy are similar to those reported in patients undergoing the surgery during infancy or childhood. So finds a newly reported review of Cleveland Clinic experience with the procedure in adults, which also revealed prognostic indicators of postoperative outcomes.
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
“Hemispherectomy is rarely performed after childhood for refractory epilepsy, when it is feared that risks to language, cognition and motor skills may be too high,” says Cleveland Clinic epileptologist Ahsan N. V. Moosa, MD, primary investigator of the study, which was published in Epilepsia (2019 Nov 2 [Epub ahead of print]) and presented on December 7 at the American Epilepsy Society’s 2019 annual meeting. “But we found that this surgery is also safe and effective after age 16, and we identified factors that can inform preoperative counseling.”
When indicated for refractory epilepsy secondary to a large, unilateral hemispheric lesion, hemispherectomy is usually performed in infancy or childhood to take advantage of the time of optimal neural plasticity. Long-term seizure freedom rates following hemispherectomy in childhood are reported to be about 66% to 80%. Because the procedure is so uncommonly performed in older age groups, less is known about immediate outcomes in this setting, and no longitudinal data were available.
This study reviewed 47 consecutive patients who were at least 16 years old when they underwent hemispherectomy between 1996 and 2016 at Cleveland Clinic’s Epilepsy Center. Preoperatively, 93% of patients had seizures either daily or weekly.
The mean age at surgery was 26.4 years, with age cohorts breaking down as follows:
Most patients acquired their epileptogenic lesion well before the surgery, as follows:
Nearly half of etiologies (47%) were attributed to perinatal stroke. Other causes included malformations of cortical development (15%) and other acquired conditions (30%), including Rasmussen encephalitis, trauma and encephalitis.
The following outcomes were found over mean postsurgical follow-up of 5.4 years (median, 2.9 years):
Multivariate analysis revealed two factors associated with seizure recurrence after hemispherectomy:
Although acute postoperative seizures are often regarded as transient and attributable to perioperative stresses, Dr. Moosa notes that they may be a predictor of poorer prognosis, especially in patients with severe epilepsy preoperatively. None of the patients who had Engel class I outcomes showed epileptic activity in the contralateral hemisphere postoperatively.
Nevertheless, Dr. Moosa emphasizes, bilateral or generalized epileptiform discharges seen on preoperative EEG should not disqualify a patient from consideration for hemispherectomy; such features were found in one-third of the patients who became seizure-free postoperatively.
In general, better preoperative motor function — and lack of cerebral peduncle atrophy on preoperative MRI (which was usually associated with it) — correlated with worsened motor function postoperatively. This was true for both ambulatory status and hand function.
According to Dr. Moosa, it is perhaps not surprising that outcomes of adult hemispherectomy were similar to those of hemispherectomy performed in childhood because most of the adult patients in this cohort experienced their brain injury in childhood.
“One might regard most of these patients as pediatric hemispherectomy candidates who had their surgery in adulthood,” he explains. “Our results suggest that neural plasticity and language transfer across hemispheres are determined by the age at brain injury, not by when surgery is performed.”
Real-world claims data and tissue culture studies set the stage for randomized clinical testing
New grant-funded investigation illustrates impact and reach of Cleveland Clinic Brain Study
How the new longitudinal investigation could become the Framingham Heart Study of brain health
Pilot findings show good patient acceptance and safety, early hints of efficacy
Study finds high prevalence of symptoms, willingness to seek treatment
Panel outlines research priorities around a promising alternative to imaging markers
Suspected factors include antithrombotic intensity, time on device, presence of thrombocytopenia
Preclinical studies will assess whether method developed for stroke recovery curbs deficits after brain injury