March 30, 2015

The Psychosocial Aspect of Cancer Care

Patients’ mental health needs benefit from evidence-based interventions

m-health_690x380 cancer

In addition to grappling with the physical challenges associated with treatment, recovery and survivorship, cancer patients often battle anxiety, depression and stress. A 2008 report published by the Institute of Medicine (IOM) notes that these mental health issues can affect health outcomes by decreasing patients’ motivation to complete treatment and reducing their ability to cope with the demands of a rigorous treatment process. “The failure to address the very real psychosocial health needs of patients and their caregivers is a failure to effectively treat that patient’s cancer,” the IOM report concludes.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Cleveland Clinic’s Taussig Cancer Institute has offered an array of support services to cancer patients and families for several years, says staff clinical psychologist Beth Gardini Dixon, PsyD. But in recent years, the Cancer Institute has devoted additional resources to psychosocial needs.

Dr. Dixon points to a cultural shift dating to the 1970s, when breakthroughs in cancer treatment gradually led to greater numbers of long-term survivors, and stigmatization of mental disorders began to diminish. Caregivers started to discuss the psychological aspects of cancer. More recently, “we began to realize how greatly the quality of life for these survivors was impacted by post-treatment distress, ” Dr. Dixon says. “We have directed attention to interventions for those undergoing active treatment, as well as for those in survivorship.”

A focused approach

Taussig Caner Institute Chairman Brian Bolwell, MD, and Isabel Schuermeyer, MD, Director of the Psycho-Oncology Program, viewed the lack of a dedicated psychologist as a “service gap” and brought Dr. Dixon in two years ago to run the Cancer Institute’s first psychology clinic, complementing other services such as psychiatry, peer support, social work, and music and art therapy.

“Depression, in particular, has been a major focus because it’s the most common mental disorder that we see among people with cancer,” Dr. Dixon notes. “Depressed patients tend to have more treatment complications. There tend to be delays in treatment as a result of the depression in comparison with non-depressed patients, and they tend to have more difficulty getting through their treatment. Fortunately, we have a growing body of research supporting the effectiveness of treatment for depression and anxiety, and of fatigue management.”

Advertisement

For example, the authors of a comprehensive 2008 article in CA: A Cancer Journal for Physicians summarized the findings of previous systematic reviews and meta-analyses of the effects of psychosocial interventions on anxiety and depression in adults with cancer. Among the 14 publications they reviewed that reached a conclusion about efficacy, six reached positive conclusions about interventions for anxiety, and nine for depression (some publications addressed both conditions). Nonpharmacological interventions showing benefits in randomized controlled studies included cognitive-behavioral therapy, relaxation training, education and couples therapy, among others.

Dr. Dixon says she has adapted evidence-based interventions from her general mental health background to the needs of individual cancer patients. One example is behavior activation therapy, intended for depressed cancer patients who have lost the motivation to pursue activities that previously brought them joy and fulfillment. “For example, maybe athletics was an important part of their life, and they’ve experienced neuropathy as a result of chemotherapy,” she explains. “I use this intervention to help them rethink what was important to them about exercise and modify that. So maybe they can’t run a marathon any more, but they can perform other activities that help them re-establish ties to their former self.”

Additional efficacy research needed

The authors of the CA review also interpret psychosocial interventions broadly to include guided imagery, music therapy, stress management and support groups. Dr. Dixon says that while all these approaches to care have enthusiastic supporters, not all are supported by evidence derived from randomized controlled trials — a gap that researchers may be able to address in the future.

“We don’t have good studies on treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder in this population, and some people do develop trauma symptoms in response to the diagnosis and treatment of cancer,” she says. “Certainly support groups offer another area where we need more research on efficacy.”

Advertisement

Stacey Carabin, RN, OCN, Program Coordinator of the Cancer Institute’s 4th Angel Mentoring Program, expresses the need for further research addressing the effectiveness of peer mentoring among cancer patients and their lay caregivers.

Meanwhile, she emphasizes the 4th Angel Mentoring Program’s value to its current participants, who hail from all 50 states. “In oncology, we as clinicians can explain drugs and procedures very well, and we can give patients an idea of what to expect,” she says. “But we can’t tell you how you’re going to feel. You get a completely different perspective when you can talk to someone who gets what you’re feeling, what your questions are, your thoughts and fears.”

Related Articles

The Featured Image for the post
January 3, 2024
Photo Essay: Support Services at Cleveland Clinic

Palliative and Supportive Care Teams offer comprehensive care to improve the lives of patients facing cancer

23-CNR-4283974-CQD-Hero-650×450 palliative care
November 15, 2023
Symptom Resolution Achieved in More than 90 Percent of Patients Under Palliative Care

Newer medications pivotal for improving gastrointestinal symptoms in patients with cancer

23-CNR-3826412-CQD-Podcast-Hero-650×450 psycho oncology
May 2, 2023
Providing Psycho-Oncology Support (Podcast)

Helping patients with cancer struggling with depression, anxiety and other mental health issues

TRAC clinic
February 7, 2023
Taussig Rapid Access Clinic Reduces Emergency Room Visits for Patients with Cancer

Majority of 1,000 patients seen in 2022 discharged home

Stomach problem
December 29, 2021
Managing Intractable Nausea and Vomiting in the Palliative Care Setting

Identifying the underlying cause key to successful treatment

endocrinology and geriatrics
February 8, 2021
New NCCN Guidelines Focus on Key Aspects of Survivorship

Patient resources promote healthy living, management of late and long-term side effects

hyperthermia-690×380
March 26, 2020
Hyperthermia Combined with Radiotherapy Can Improve Pain Control and Survival in Patients with Cancer

Research and clinical experience indicate that hyperthermia boosts the efficacy of radiotherapy

19-CNR-882 – 650×450-Cancer-Patient-and-Financial-Navigator
June 1, 2019
Financial Navigator Support Pays Off for Cancer Patients and Providers

Reducing uncollectible revenue, financial burden

Ad