February 2, 2017/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle

A New Concern: Ankle Valgus after Hindfoot Fusion

Valgus tibiotalar tilt tough to treat, common

16-ORT-2647 Miniaci ConsultQD_650x450

By Sara Lyn Miniaci-Coxhead, MD


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Arthrodesis of the hindfoot is a common, reliable option for treatment of arthritis and deformity involving the subtalar, talonavicular and calcaneocuboid joints. The development of valgus tibiotalar tilt of the ankle joint has been noted as a complication of these procedures. Only limited data examine the incidence and predictive factors of valgus tibiotalar tilt following hindfoot fusion. We sought with this study to define the incidence of valgus tibiotalar tilt, and to identify any pre- or postoperative radiographic parameters that may predict its postop development.

Valgus tibiotalar tilt tough to treat, common

Valgus tibiotalar tilt is a tough phenomenon to treat given deltoid ligament insufficiency and the limited options for deltoid ligament reconstruction. In addition, ankle joint incongruity leads to accelerated wear due to increased eccentric contact pressures. This can lead to ankle arthritis, another difficult problem with limited surgical treatment options.

We retrospectively reviewed all patients over a 10-year period who underwent a subtalar, subtalar and talonavicular (double), or subtalar, talonavicular and calcaneocuboid (triple) arthrodesis. Exclusion criteria included an ankle arthrodesis, a revision procedure, total ankle arthroplasty or a deltoid ligament reconstruction at the time of the index procedure. Patients were also excluded if the indication for surgery was a cavus foot deformity or Charcot arthropathy, or if they did not have a complete set of weight-bearing foot and ankle radiographs (pre- and postoperative).

16-ORT-2647 Miniaci ConsultQD Inset 1

Figure 1. Preop (above) and postop (below) radiographs of a patient who developed tibiotalar tilt postop.

A total of 187 patients were eligible for the study. The average age was 52 (11 to 82) years. The most common indication for surgery was adult-acquired flatfoot deformity (92, 49.2 percent), followed by arthritis (83, 44.4 percent). The most common procedure was a triple arthrodesis (101, 54 percent). A total of 51 patients (27.3 percent) developed valgus tibiotalar tilt postoperatively, at an average time of 3.6 months after surgery (Figure 1).


Standardized measurements were taken on both pre- and postoperative films. These measurements were previously described as appropriate in the evaluation of pes planus. We found that an increase in preoperative Meary’s (lateral talar-first metatarsal) angle (hazard ratio 1.039, CI: 1.002-1.077; P < 0.05) was associated with development of valgus tibiotalar tilt. An increase in postoperative Meary’s angle (hazard ratio 1.052, CI: 0.999- 1.108, P = 0.0528) approached significance for development of tibiotalar tilt. We found that patients with larger or undercorrected deformities were more likely to develop tibiotalar tilt.

16-ORT-2647 Miniaci ConsultQD Inset 2

Figure 2. A. A large preoperative deformity. B. An undercorrected deformity.

Fusion and deltoid ligament attenuation lead to tilt

A review of multiple cadaver studies revealed that the development of valgus tibiotalar tilt appears to be related to strain and incompetence of the deltoid ligament. In a patient with a flatfoot deformity, weight-bearing forces dissipate throughout the hindfoot, allowing the tibiotalar joint to remain in appropriate alignment. However, once the hindfoot is fused, it lacks flexibility. This rigidity, combined with deltoid ligament attenuation, leads to eccentric forces through the tibiotalar joint, producing valgus tibiotalar tilt.

Alert patients to risk, assess deltoid

This information has an important impact on our surgical practice. First, high-risk patients should be informed about the risks and consequences of valgus tibiotalar tilt.

Operative planning should center on a reconstruction-based procedure rather than a fusion when feasible, as this would allow hindfoot flexibility. Also, surgeons should assess and consider possible reconstruction of the deltoid ligament at the time of correction, in hopes of preventing tibiotalar tilt.


Our ongoing research in this area will compare the outcomes of patients who do and do not develop tibiotalar tilt. We are also examining the role of deltoid ligament stress during a hindfoot fusion and the efficacy of deltoid ligament reconstruction at the time of the index procedure. The more we learn about the development and impact of tibiotalar tilt, the more we can avoid further morbidity for our patients.

Dr. Miniaci-Coxhead is associate staff in the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery. She would like to acknowledge coauthors for this project, A. Samuel Flemister, MD, and John P. Ketz, MD, at the University of Rochester, Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, in Rochester, NY.

Related Articles

22-ORI-3184567 CQD 650&#215;450
November 3, 2022/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
Great Toe Pain: First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusion Has Excellent Outcomes

Pain, quality of life and other patient-reported data are significantly improved one year after surgery

21-ORI-2415308 CQD 650&#215;450
October 25, 2021/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
When Is Total Ankle Replacement the Best Treatment Option?

Ankle arthritis can be more disabling than hip or knee arthritis

A New Frontier in Ankle Replacements

Staged cavus repair and total ankle arthroplasty

November 16, 2017/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
Why Do Bunion Surgeries Fail?

Causes are multifactorial, but good surgical decision-making and technique reduce failures