Locations:

Nonresponse to CRT: A Case Study in Systematic Troubleshooting

Multidisciplinary assessment helps minimize poor outcomes

Nonresponse to CRT: A Case Study in Systematic Troubleshooting

By John Rickard, MD, MPH

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

History and presentation

Mr. JL is a 48-year-old African-American male who until one year ago had a medical history significant only for obstructive sleep apnea, for which he intermittently used continuous positive airway pressure therapy. He noted at his job as a construction worker that he was becoming progressively short of breath during routine tasks and was eventually referred to a cardiologist in his local community. Echocardiography showed significant left ventricular dysfunction, with a left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) of 20 percent. Left heart catheterization showed normal coronary arteries. He was started on carvedilol 12.5 mg twice daily, lisinopril 10 mg daily and furosemide 80 mg daily. He continued to have significant symptoms but was able to return to work.

Repeat echocardiography six months after diagnosis revealed his LVEF to still be 20 percent despite optimal medical therapy. As a result, he was referred for implantation of a biventricular defibrillator. A percutaneous left ventricular lead could not be placed, so he was referred for surgical left ventricular lead placement, which he underwent successfully at an outside institution. He was discharged in stable condition.

Over the next six months, his symptoms continued to worsen. He could no longer work and was hospitalized for heart failure. When a follow-up echocardiogram showed that his LVEF had dropped to 15 percent, he was referred to Cleveland Clinic’s Cardiac Resynchronization Therapy Optimization Clinic.

CRT Optimization Clinic at a glance

This specialized clinic (detailed in this earlier post) employs an algorithmic approach for patients who have not responded to cardiac resynchronization therapy (CRT) as much as was expected in terms of echocardiographic and/or symptomatic improvement. The clinic uses a multidisciplinary model — with input from electrophysiologists, heart failure and imaging cardiologists, cardiothoracic surgeons and sometimes other subspecialists — to discuss findings from the algorithm-driven examination, determine potential reasons for inadequate CRT response and establish a treatment plan to optimize response and long-term outcomes.

Advertisement

Case continued at Cleveland Clinic

Physical examination revealed volume overload, a nonischemic cardiomyopathy of only one year’s duration, grade 2+ lower extremity edema and faint bibasilar rales. Comprehensive device evaluation showed 99 percent biventricular pacing with excellent function of all leads. Twelve-lead ECG was performed (Figure 1, left panel) and showed a paced pattern with a deep S wave in lead V1, raising potential questions about lead position. Adequate capture of the left ventricular lead was confirmed, and no anodal stimulation was noted.

Figure 1. The patient’s ECGs upon presentation (left) and with suppression of biventricular pacing (right).

Figure 1. The patient’s ECGs upon presentation (top) and with suppression of biventricular pacing (bottom).

Suppression of pacing revealed a wide underlying left bundle branch block (Figure 1, right panel), suggesting a highly conducive substrate for response to CRT. When chest X-ray showed an anterior/anterolateral surgically placed left ventricular lead (Figure 2), this was determined to be the likely culprit for CRT nonresponse following discussion at a multidisciplinary conference.

Figure 2. Lateral chest X-ray showing an anterior/anterolateral left ventricular pacing lead.

Figure 2. Lateral chest X-ray showing an anterior/anterolateral left ventricular pacing lead.

A copy of the patient’s coronary sinus venogram was then obtained (Figure 3) to determine whether another attempt at percutaneous placement would be reasonable. The venogram showed two potential targets:

  • The lateral branch was relatively small and tortuous at the proximal portion with a trifurcating system at the ostium that could be accessed but apparently would not accept a lead.
  • The posterolateral branch was moderately sized, but a stenosis in its midsection made it unable to accept a lead, although a wire could pass beyond it.

Advertisement

Figure 3. Coronary sinus venogram showing potential targets for percutaneous coronary sinus lead placement at the lateral and posterolateral branches.

Figure 3. Coronary sinus venogram showing potential targets for percutaneous coronary sinus lead placement at the lateral and posterolateral branches.

A repeat attempt at surgical lead placement was considered, but consultation with cardiothoracic surgery colleagues determined that the patient was not an ideal candidate due to anatomical constraints. A CRT optimization echocardiogram with three-dimensional strain imaging was performed, showing worsened cardiac performance with CRT on versus off.

In view of these collective findings, the CRT Optimization Clinic’s multidisciplinary team made a final recommendation to proceed with a repeat attempt at percutaneous coronary sinus lead placement targeting the posterolateral branch. The recommendation calls for interventional cardiology assistance to perform venoplasty of the stenotic midsection of the vessel to allow passage of the lead. As of this writing, the procedure has been scheduled but not yet performed.

The case for CRT optimization

CRT has been a godsend for individuals with advanced heart failure, but as many as one-third of patients fail to respond to CRT. In the absence of a thorough multidisciplinary assessment, these patients are at increased risk for poor exercise tolerance, repeat hospitalizations and early death.

At Cleveland Clinic, we recommend that all patients who receive a CRT device be re-evaluated with an echocardiogram within six to nine months. At that point, patients who have realized little to no benefit should undergo “troubleshooting” of their care to systematically identify possible reasons for nonresponse. We have created our CRT Optimization Clinic, one of the few programs of its type in the nation, to deliver that troubleshooting in a way that ensures a collaborative, multidisciplinary approach guided by a thorough, algorithm-directed evaluation.

Advertisement

The clinic’s collaborative ethos extends to fully include patients and their referring cardiologists. If a major intervention is required (e.g., reoperation to move a lead), the recommendation is discussed with the referring clinician and a plan is formulated. If only minor device changes are needed or no significant interventions are possible, patients are followed by their referring cardiologist with Cleveland Clinic’s CRT Optimization Clinic acting in a consultative role.

Dr. Rickard is an electrophysiologist and Director of Cleveland Clinic’s CRT Program.

Advertisement

Related Articles

color cardiac echo next to model of a bulging aorta

Distinctive CME on Valve Imaging and Connective Tissue Disorders on Tap for March 2027

In-depth live symposia in Florida and Cleveland feature interdisciplinary experts from around the nation

yellow and red illustration of blood cells moving through a blood vessel

First-in-Human Data Show One siRNA Can Lower Both LDL-C and Triglycerides

Early results for ARO-DIMER-PA point to a more streamlined way to treat mixed hyperlipidemia

blood vessel on top of a DNA double helix

CRISPR-Cas9 Gene Editing Therapy Safely Slashes Severely Elevated Triglycerides in Early Trial

Findings support further studies of potential one-time treatment strategy

two side-by-side medical illustrations with red trend line overlays

Lipoprotein(a) Reduction With Pelacarsen Has No Impact on Cardiac Events, Lp(a)HORIZON Finds

But unexpected results are ‘not the end of the story’ for Lp(a) lowering, investigators say

stylized heart and lungs with text overlay

Outcome Updates in Adult Cardiac Surgery, Ischemic Heart Disease and Vascular Disease

A scannable snapshot of recent volumes and results

illustration of aortic arch after stent graft repair

Evolving Strategies in Aortic Arch Repair (Podcast)

Earlier detection is reshaping timing and safety of these increasingly common surgeries

illustrated human gut with microbes and an overlay of a rhythm tracing

TMAO Shown to Be a Modifiable Risk Factor for Atrial Fibrillation

Bench-to-bedside study identifies mechanism and potential therapeutic target

heart scan with blue and yellow arrow overlays

A Case Study in Team-Based Care and Research-Driven Practice

Integrating research and clinical care can yield reciprocal rewards

Ad