Targeted Neoadjuvant Therapy For High-Complexity Cases of Renal Masses in a Solitary Kidney

Management of high-risk RMSK in the pre-and current eras of neoadjuvant therapy

Tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI) in the neoadjuvant setting are associated with greater use of partial nephrectomy (PN) when treating patients diagnosed with renal masses in a solitary kidney (RMSK), according to the findings of a new Cleveland Clinic study. While randomized, controlled trials are needed, these findings support the use of TKI, still considered an experimental neoadjuvant therapy, in select patients with RMSK.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

They published their findings in European Urology Oncology.

New questions arise in the management of RMSK

This is the latest RMSK series from Steven C. Campbell, MD, PhD, Worapat Attawettayanon, BS, and colleagues, who recently updated their experience with this challenging patient population in 2022. The research team published a comprehensive review that assessed outcomes from more than 1,000 patients diagnosed with RMSK at Cleveland Clinic between 1975 and 2022. The 2022 study is among the largest series of RMSK outcomes to date and the first to include all RMSK patients — not just those who underwent successful PN.

It also inspired new questions about the management of patients with the most complex cases of RMSK.

“Coming out of that study, we asked ourselves, ‘What can we learn about the most challenging RMSK cases?’ These are the cases with the highest risk of postoperative complications or loss of renal function. The ones with a RENAL score of 10 to 12,” Dr. Campbell explains.

These are the cases where there is no room for error. Complications could mean converting to radical nephrectomy and, ultimately, progression to dialysis. Though precarious, high-complexity RMSK is relatively uncommon. Still, Dr. Campbell says, most urologists will likely encounter a few of these cases in their professional lifetime.

Introduction of TKIs for kidney cancers

Cleveland Clinic began administering TKI as a neoadjuvant therapy for RMSK in 2009. The medication is an angiogenesis inhibitor, blocking the vascular endothelial growth factor receptors involved in the growth of clear cell renal cell carcinoma — a tumor subtype that accounts for about 70% of kidney cancers.

In the right patients, it offers a clear benefit. “You might have a 7 cm tumor shrink to a 5 cm tumor, which sounds modest, but this is significant if it offers greater accessibility, making the surgery less technically challenging, and allowing us to save more renal parenchyma,” he explains.

Analysis of high-complexity RMSK cases

The research team extracted data from the Cleveland Clinic kidney cancer database (1999-2022), resulting in 499 records with an available RENAL score, a validated metric to classify renal tumors based on quantifiable characteristics, and focused on patients with scores of 10 to 12, resulting in 133 patients for analysis.


They then divided the dataset into two cohorts: patients who predated the availability of TKI (1999-2008) (N = 80) and patients managed when neoadjuvant TKI could be considered, based on the date of their surgery (2009-2022) (N = 53).

Their analysis found that 43% (23/53) of patients with clear cell histology in the TKI era were selected for the neoadjuvant therapy. Overall, these 23 patients had a greater median tumor diameter and RENAL score than their counterparts not selected for the neoadjuvant therapy. These were the most challenging of cases. And, generally, they responded well to TKI therapy. A decrease was noted in the median tumor diameter (from 7.1 cm to 5.6 cm) and RENAL score (from 11 to 9). Tumor volume was reduced by 59%.

Nearly all of these patients (21/23), or 91%, were able to be managed with PN. Overall, in the TKI era, 48/53 (90%) of patients were managed with PN. In contrast, in the pre-TKI era, only 65% (52/80) were able to be managed with PN.

Figure. Imaging before and after TKI therapy for a patient with biopsy-proven clear-cell RCC in a solitary kidney. (A,B) Before TKI treatment, the tumor was 4.5 cm, entirely endophytic, and adjacent to the main vascular branches coming out of the hilum, with a RENAL score of 11. The patient was then treated with 8 weeks of axitinib. (C,D) Post-TKI imaging shows a smaller tumor size and substantial tumor necrosis; the RENAL score had decreased to 10. The tumor also pulled away from the hilum to some degree. The patient underwent open clamped partial nephrectomy with hypothermia. Pathology demonstrated grade 2 clear-cell RCC with negative margins. Surgery preserved 77% of the glomerular filtration rate, and the patient is cancer-free with stable renal function after 2 yr of follow-up. RCC = renal cell carcinoma; TKI = tyrosine kinase inhibitor.


Image and caption have been republished under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0). Originally published by Attawettayanon W, Yasuda Y, Zhang JH, Kazama A, Rathi N, Munoz-Lopez C, Lewis K, Shah S, Li J, Emrich Accioly JP, Campbell RA, Shah S, Wood A, Kaouk J, Haber GP, Eltemamy M, Krishnamurthi V, Abouassaly R, Weight C, Derweesh I, Campbell SC. Selective Use of Neoadjuvant Targeted Therapy Is Associated with Greater Achievement of Partial Nephrectomy for High-complexity Renal Masses in a Solitary Kidney. Eur Urol Open Sci. 2023 Jun 10;54:1-9.

New evidence in a limited dataset

Dr. Campbell acknowledges that a randomized, controlled trial would offer a higher level of evidence about the use of TKI therapy in this patient population. But their data provide new information on a historically limited dataset, setting the stage for continued investigations.

Still, he advises prudent use of TKI therapy and careful consideration of the cost-benefit for patients. Clear cell histology alone is not an indication for TKI therapy, and if there is limited benefit to downsizing the tumor from the surgeon’s perspective, the patient may proceed with surgery and PN without TKI therapy. But in cases with more complicated tumors, the advantages of TKI cannot be overlooked.

“In cases where the tumor shrinks substantially — well, that can turn an incredibly difficult case into an easy one,” Dr. Campbell concludes.

Featured image: Imaging shows before and after TKI therapy for a patient with biopsy-proven clear-cell RCC in a solitary kidney. See figure for full description.


Related Articles

URL_Pavelko_3777858_Urology_Dr. Lundy in Clinic_04-26-23_LDJ
September 28, 2023/Urology & Nephrology/Research
Study Suggests Broader Use of Anastrozole for Male Infertility

Findings expand upon earlier data, providing new noninvasive options

Kidney lithotripsy procedure Etracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy for remove
September 20, 2023/Urology & Nephrology/Research
Novel Approach Shows Efficacy in Fragmenting Kidney Stones

Cleveland Clinic is the first to investigate photonic nanoparticles as a potential kidney stone treatment

Heart and kidneys
Models Using Basic Blood Tests Predict Acute Kidney Injury After Cardiac Surgery

The multidisciplinary research team reported their findings in JAMA

21-URL-2271032 CQD 650×450
December 13, 2021/Urology & Nephrology/Research
Mapping Out the Genitourinary Microbiome

Information on the microbiome and urologic pathologies remain relatively limited

Human Urinary System Bladder Anatomy
Researchers to Conduct Comprehensive Analysis of the Human Bladder and Ureter

New grant will fund work to map human bladder and ureter at a cellular and molecular level

September 13, 2021/Urology & Nephrology/Research
The UroMonitor Advances to In-Human Trials

First in-human-trial for diagnostic bladder disorder device