What is the Sweet Spot for Diabetes Control in Chronic Kidney Disease?

The target may be different than what you expect

650×450 HbA

A new observational analysis of 6,165 patients with diabetes and chronic kidney disease (CKD) shows a target hemoglobin A1c (HbA1c) of 6-6.9 percent minimizes the likelihood of diabetes-related death.

Advertisement

Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

All other factors aside, patients whose diabetes was tightly controlled, as measured by HbA1c levels below 6 percent, had similar risk of death as patients with levels higher than 9 percent, according to the same study.

“This study confirmed for us there really is a sweet spot in HbA1c levels for patients with diabetes and chronic kidney disease,” says Joseph Nally Jr., MD, now-retired Director of the Center for Chronic Kidney Disease in Cleveland Clinic’s Glickman Urological & Kidney Institute. “The further away patients get from 7.5 percent HbA1c in either direction, the average risk for negative outcomes rises significantly.”

HbA1c Levels and All-cause Mortality

When considered as a continuous variable, HbA1c level was significantly associated with pre-ESRD mortality. The relationship was nonlinear, with very low and high HbA1c levels having the higher risk for mortality and risk being lowest at HbA1c levels of about 7 to 8 percent. (Figure copyrighted by and reprinted with permission from the American Journal of Kidney Diseases.)

Advertisement

Published in the American Journal of Kidney Diseases, the study included a median follow-up of 2.3 years on people with diabetes (both Type 1 and Type 2) who were patients at Cleveland Clinic.

Among the primary reasons that lower HbA1c can put diabetic patients with kidney disease at increased risk of death is that having CKD predisposes patients to hypoglycemia, itself a life-threatening and emergent condition, according to the study.

Dr. Nally says these findings can help providers “educate their patients on the importance of getting to that target hemoglobin HbA1c of 6 to 7 percent when they have kidney disease and let them know of the very poor outcomes that can be associated with levels that are either too high or too low.”

Advertisement

The study, Diabetes Control and the Risks of ESRD and Mortality in Patients with CKD, was conducted by Dr. Nally; Jesse Schold, PhD; Stacey Jolly, MD; Susana Arrigain, MS; and colleagues at Baylor College of Medicine.

Related Articles

Man sitting at kitchen table with blood pressure monitor and pill bottles
Should Patients Take Blood Pressure Medications in the Evening to Enhance Cardiovascular Benefit?

Clinicians should individualize dosing practices based on patient risk factors and preferences

Drawing of a pink bulb with two tubes coming out of the top
Predicting Post-Op GFR: AI Algorithm Is as Accurate as Clinical Model

Fully-automated process uses preop CT, baseline GFR to estimate post-nephrectomy renal function

Arm of Black patient having kidney dialysis
GFR Equations: How Will Eliminating the Race Coefficient Affect Black Patients?

Could mean earlier treatment, but also could have negative effects

Senior at the Doctors
Study Assesses the Utility of Renal Genetic Testing in Black Patients

Identifying barriers in the renal genetic assessment of Black patients

GUKI Care Page of Dr. George Thomas and Angela Smith
Resistant Hypertension: A Stepwise Approach

Getting patients to their goal blood pressure

urine bottle held by healthcare professionals with latex glove, toxicology test
Nephrologist-Led Urine Microscopy Edges Out Automated Technology in Predicting AKI

Study highlights benefits of nephrologist-led urine sediment analysis

23-URL-3773974-CQD-650×450-1
New Data Suggest Kidney Diseases With No Known Cause May Be Linked to Viruses

Using sequencing data to identify novel factors linked to kidney disease with unknown origin

650×450-Wang
A 3-Year Review of Real-World Experience in the Renal Genetics Clinic

Program plays key role in diagnosis and management of genetic kidney diseases

Ad