MIDCAB: A Case Study in Its Benefits, Considerations for Patient Selection

Matching the minimally invasive CABG alternative to the right candidates

Case vignette

In August 2020, a 62-year-old male triathlete arranged a virtual visit with clinical cardiologist Tamanna Singh, MD, Co-Director of Cleveland Clinic’s Sports Cardiology Center. After hearing Dr. Singh on a recent podcast on heart health and running, he became concerned that his recent jaw pain and decline in stamina might be atypical symptoms of heart disease. Based on the virtual visit, Dr. Singh recommended that he have a cardiac catheterization done locally. When it revealed a severely diseased left anterior descending artery (LAD) and diseased circumflex artery, he came to Cleveland Clinic for an in-person evaluation.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Because the patient had a history of pericarditis, Dr. Singh ordered a cardiac MRI to rule out active inflammation or constriction effect on the heart; she also ordered a repeat catheterization to confirm the location and extent of his coronary artery disease. The catheterization, performed by interventional cardiologist Jaikirshan Khatri, MD, included pressure-wire interrogation of the circumflex. When this was negative, Dr. Khatri confirmed that the patient’s disease was confined to the LAD.

Since revascularization via coronary artery bypass grafting or stenting would be necessary, Drs. Singh and Khatri met with cardiothoracic surgeon Faisal Bakaeen, MD, to discuss treatment options. A significant intramyocardial segment of LAD identified by Dr. Khatri on catheterization made stenting unwise. Dr. Bakaeen felt the patient would be an excellent candidate for minimally invasive direct coronary artery bypass (MIDCAB) grafting and would derive greater benefit from bypass grafting than stenting, owing to his age and activity level and the large myocardial territory he had at risk. The patient agreed to proceed with MIDCAB so long as all attempts would be made to avoid sternotomy.

The patient was anesthetized and prepared for off-pump surgery. Dr. Bakaeen made a small left thoracotomy incision, harvested the internal thoracic artery (ITA) and connected it to the LAD distal to the obstruction.

Graft flow was measured with a flowmeter and found to be ideal. After heparin was reversed, graft flow was rechecked and continued to be excellent. The wound was closed, and the patient was sent to the ICU. Two days later, graft patency was confirmed by coronary CT angiogram. The patient’s recovery was uneventful, and he was discharged home on postoperative day three. He is pleased with the limited extent of his scar (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Photo of the patient’s postoperative scar.

Considerations behind the case

Although single-vessel disease is often treated medically or with stenting, MIDCAB offers many advantages for appropriately selected patients with suitable anatomy.

In this patient, borderline findings of disease in the circumflex artery seen on the first angiogram were ruled out with a second catheterization and pressure-wire interrogation. Concerns about potential constriction due to pericarditis were eliminated with an MRI.


Although the patient was leaning toward stenting to avoid a sternotomy, the team explained that because a segment of his LAD was buried in the myocardium, a stent would not be optimal due to a risk of continued symptoms and an increased risk of sudden cardiac death.

MIDCAB would be a better option, they noted, since an ITA graft to the LAD is likely to stay open in perpetuity.

MIDCAB advantages

In addition to being durable, MIDCAB offers advantages over traditional on-pump coronary artery bypass grafting, such as less scarring, shorter length of stay, less pain and quicker recovery. Because the operation is typically done off pump, patients experience less bleeding and potentially fewer complications and have lower risk of atrial fibrillation and stroke.

With a sternotomy, strenuous activity and heavy lifting are restricted for six to eight weeks as the sternum heals. With MIDCAB, those restrictions are loosened and governed by pain levels.

“Patients can gradually increase their activity,” says Dr. Bakaeen. “Once they feel no pain, they can generally perform most activities with few limitations.”

Patient selection, quality control

A key initial consideration for MIDCAB candidacy is making absolutely certain the patient has single-vessel LAD disease, says Dr. Khatri. “MIDCAB is not technically feasible if the patient has multivessel disease,” he explains. Other important considerations are the patient’s chest anatomy and the location and quality of the LAD target.

In addition to careful patient selection and input from a multidisciplinary heart team, successful MIDCAB requires quality control. At Cleveland Clinic, this is done by measuring graft flow in the operating room and often verifying graft patency with CT coronary angiography prior to discharge (Figure 2).


“This gives us a look at graft functionality and anatomy and provides confidence the graft is working well,” Dr. Bakaeen explains.

Figure 2. CT coronary angiogram showing a patent left ITA (LITA) with clips on its branches (bright white) anastomosed to the LAD beyond the diseased and calcified segments (also bright white).

Safety first

As with other minimally invasive procedures, MIDCAB cannot always be guaranteed. Sometimes the patient’s anatomy or condition prevents carrying out the approach as planned. When this occurs, the surgeon makes adaptations to ensure the patient has the best outcome.

“We always start with a very small incision between the ribs,” says Dr. Bakaeen, “but if the LAD cannot be adequately exposed or if other factors preclude a safe or effective MIDCAB approach, then we have no hesitation to convert to sternotomy with or without use of a heart-lung machine. We never compromise safety or outcomes.”

In this case, the MIDCAB went as planned. “MIDCAB was a fantastic option for this patient, and he was very happy with the outcome,” concludes Dr. Singh.

Related Articles

intraoperative photo of robotic tracheobronchoplasty
Robotically Assisted Tracheobronchoplasty: A Case Study

Excessive dynamic airway collapse presenting as dyspnea and exercise intolerance in a 67-year-old

22-HVI-2987079 CQD 650×450
Off-Label Endovascular Intervention for Giant Aortic Arch Aneurysm: A Case Study

Necessity breeds innovation when patient doesn’t qualify for standard treatment or trials

22-HVI-3200903 CQD 650×450
Case Study: A Young Man With Nonischemic Cardiomyopathy and Uncontrolled VT

After optimized medical and device therapy, is there a role for endocardial-epicardial VT ablation?

22-HVI-2958608-1 650×450
When the Ross Procedure Fails: Fifth Operation Offers Young Man a New Start

Fever and aortic root bleeding two decades post-Ross procedure

Case Study: When Lung Transplant Evaluation Reveals a Large Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm

How to time the interventions, and how to manage anesthesia risks?

The Ross Procedure in a Reoperative Setting: A Case Study

A potentially definitive repair in a young woman with multiple prior surgeries

A Longtime Alliance Partner Sees Benefits From Collaboration on Clinical Projects and Beyond

Initiatives cover everything from STS performance metrics to facility renovations