Red Flag or False Alarm? When to Cath After High Systolic PA Pressure on Echo

By Mostafa Ahmed, MD; Raed A. Dweik, MD; and Adriano R. Tonelli, MD

Despite significant advances in therapy in the last three decades, pulmonary artery hypertension (PAH) continues to lead to right heart failure and death. Evidence of PAH could be hiding in a common incidental finding on echocardiogram – elevated systolic pulmonary artery (PA) pressure.

Due to the prevalence of false positives, the recommended approaches to address high systolic PA pressure on echo vary from no further investigation to right heart catheterization and, in some cases, referral to a pulmonary hypertension center. We recently proposed a new algorithm for managing high systolic PA pressure echo findings that we hope provides a more accurate, streamlined path to PAH diagnosis.

How high is too high?

In short, we don’t know. No consensus has been established on the optimal cutoff for systolic PA pressure echo findings that should trigger further evaluation for PAH.

• One retrospective evaluation of nearly 16,000 normal echos found that the 95 percent upper limit of normal for systolic PA pressure was 37 mm Hg.
• European guidelines propose that PAH is unlikely if the estimated systolic PA pressure is 36 mm Hg or lower, possible if it is 37 to 50 mm Hg, and likely if it is higher than 50 mm Hg.
• The 2009 consensus document of the American College of Cardiology Foundation and American Heart Associationrecommends a systolic PA pressure greater than 40 mm Hg as the threshold to suggest further evaluation in a patient with unexplained dyspnea.

Our algorithm (below) uses 40 mm Hg as a limit, combined with other echocardiographic variables.

Causes of high systolic PA pressure

Table 1 shows conditions associated with high systolic PA pressure on echocardiogram. This table demonstrates that the causes of elevated systolic PA pressure on echocardiography are many and not necessarily associated with PAH. Consideration of these other factors must occur before proceeding to right heart catheterization.

Closing in on PAH

Some echocardiographic features that suggest PAH include a dilated right atrium or ventricle, flattening of the interventricular septum, notching of the right ventricular outflow tract flow and dilation of the main pulmonary artery.

However, echocardiography provides only an indirect measure of systolic PA pressure. Only a right heart catheterization can provide direct evidence of PAH through accurate pressure measurements. Studies comparing measurements during right heart cath with estimated value on echo demonstrate a reasonable degree of agreement between the tests, but a substantial variability. Echo commonly under- and over-estimates systolic PA pressure, with 95 percent limits of agreement ranging from minus 40 mm Hg to plus 40 mm Hg. A difference of plus or minus 10 mm Hg in systolic PA pressure between echocardiography and catheterization was observed in 48 to 51 percent of patients with PAH, particularly in those with higher systolic PA pressure.

To cath or not to cath?

Given the high prevalence of PAH, and the goal of reducing unnecessary procedures, the Fifth World Symposium on Pulmonary Hypertension recommended first considering heart or parenchymal lung disease when an echocardiogram suggests PAH.

Figure 1 details an algorithm we use to investigate elevated systolic PA pressure on echo. In the appropriate clinical setting, if the systolic PA pressure is 40 mm Hg or greater or if other echocardiographic variables suggest PAH, our practice is to proceed with right heart catheterization. If the estimated PA pressure is less than 40 mmHg, the right ventricular size and function are normal and the patient has no diseases associated with PAH, we would not proceed with catheterization.

Figure 1. An algorithmic approach to the assessment of systolic pulmonary artery pressure on echocardiography. Adapted in part from Fifth World Symposium on Pulmonary Hypertension recommendations.

Use algorithm to avoid unnecessary caths

In the appropriate context, a high systolic PA pressure on echocardiography suggests PAH, but right heart catheterization is needed to confirm the diagnosis. Since estimating systolic PA pressure with echocardiography has limitations, including false-positive results (predominantly when the pretest probability of PAH is low), care must be taken in both diagnosing and proceeding with additional testing. Our algorithm serves as a useful guide.

Read more about PAH on Consult QD.

What do patients want to know about pulmonary hypertension? View this Cleveland Clinic Online Health Chat with Dr. Tonelli.

Dr. Ahmed is a Research Fellow, Department of Pulmonary, Allergy, and Critical Care Medicine, Respiratory Institute.

Dr. Dweik is Director of the Pulmonary Vascular Diseases Program, Department of Pulmonary, Allergy and Critical Care Medicine, Respiratory Institute.

Dr. Tonelli is staff, Department of Pulmonary, Allergy and Critical Care Medicine, Respiratory Institute.