Case Study: Recurring Metatarsal Fracture Indicates Underlying Foot Deformity (Video)

Surgeon corrects skew foot to address repeat injuries

A 15-year-old girl presented with a fracture of her fifth metatarsal, an injury that happened while she was playing soccer. Although fifth metatarsal fracture is one of the most common foot injuries, it had occurred three times in this young patient.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

In the above video, foot and ankle surgeon Sara Lyn Miniaci-Coxhead, MD, of Cleveland Clinic’s Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, highlights the importance of evaluating foot shape and biomechanics when dealing with chronic fractures of the foot and ankle.

On exam, the patient had pain over her fifth metatarsal and evidence of a skew foot deformity, a combination of midfoot abduction and metatarsus adductus. Her radiograph showed a fifth metatarsal fracture in addition to a skew foot and bunion deformity.

The location of the fifth metatarsal fracture suggested a stress component as it was a more distal fracture, explained Dr. Miniaci-Coxhead.


“This led me to believe that only addressing the fracture would be like putting a bandage on a leaky pipe,” she said. “It would fix the fracture, but it would not address the underlying reason why she continues to break this bone — her foot shape.”

The position of the patient’s foot placed more stress on the lateral border, likely the reason she continued to break her fifth metatarsal. Dr. Miniaci-Coxhead planned to correct the foot deformity in addition to addressing the metatarsal fracture.

The surgery included a lateral column lengthening to correct the midfoot abduction and a first tarsometatarsal joint fusion to correct the metatarsus adductus. Dr. Miniaci-Coxhead corrected the fifth metatarsal through the fracture site, which allowed both deformity and fracture fixation with one plate. Finally, she performed an osteotomy of the first metatarsal to correct the bunion.


“The patient did very well after surgery and was able to return to her sporting activities, including running, without pain,” says Dr. Miniaci-Coxhead.

Related Articles

22-ORI-3184567 CQD 650×450
November 3, 2022/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
Great Toe Pain: First Metatarsophalangeal Joint Fusion Has Excellent Outcomes

Pain, quality of life and other patient-reported data are significantly improved one year after surgery

21-ORI-2415308 CQD 650×450
October 25, 2021/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
When Is Total Ankle Replacement the Best Treatment Option?

Ankle arthritis can be more disabling than hip or knee arthritis

A New Frontier in Ankle Replacements

Staged cavus repair and total ankle arthroplasty

November 16, 2017/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
Why Do Bunion Surgeries Fail?

Causes are multifactorial, but good surgical decision-making and technique reduce failures

16-ORT-2647 Miniaci ConsultQD_650x450
February 2, 2017/Orthopaedics/Foot & Ankle
A New Concern: Ankle Valgus after Hindfoot Fusion

Valgus tibiotalar tilt tough to treat, common