Search IconSearch

Isolated Tricuspid Valve Surgery for Right Heart Failure: A Call to Broaden Patient Eligibility

Also, earlier surgery likely benefits patients with severe functional TR

22-HVI-2751014 CQD 650×450

Good early outcomes of isolated tricuspid valve surgery for right heart failure support expanding surgical candidacy selection criteria. Additionally, patients with functional tricuspid regurgitation (TR) have poorer long-term outcomes than those with structural TR, which suggests they would benefit from earlier surgical intervention.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

Those are two key conclusions of an observational study from Cleveland Clinic published online ahead of print in the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery.

“Whether to operate on patients with severe tricuspid regurgitation and right heart failure is an increasingly common issue that cardiologists and cardiac surgeons struggle with,” says the study’s first author, Haytham Elgharably, MD, of Cleveland Clinic’s Department of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery. “Our experience of good early outcomes following isolated tricuspid valve surgery supports expanding candidacy criteria, as well as operating earlier on patients with functional tricuspid regurgitation.”

He adds that the good early outcomes can be attributed to a thorough assessment process for these patients before surgery, which may include cardiac MRI in addition to routine testing such as echocardiography and right/left cardiac catheterization. The evaluation is then completed by direct discussion among Cleveland Clinic’s right heart failure team, including both cardiology and cardiac surgery, to carefully select candidates for surgery. “In our experience,” Dr. Elgharably says, “two critical factors of risk assessment should be considered when planning for surgery: right ventricular function and the liver function profile. High-risk patients are evaluated for available transcatheter therapies.”

More evidence needed for determining candidacy

No standard approach exists for determining operability and likelihood of reversing right heart failure in patients with tricuspid valve disease, with a variety of clinical factors entering the equation.

Most would agree that surgery is indicated for those with normal right ventricular function and cardiac index and mild right heart failure, as such patients are generally low risk and tricuspid valve surgery is likely to achieve successful reversal.

On the other end of the spectrum, the decision not to operate is relatively easy for those with right ventricular dysfunction, low cardiac index and severe right heart failure, as such patients are at high surgical risk and reversal of heart failure is unlikely.


Not so clear-cut, however, is what to do in settings between these extremes — i.e., in patients with normal right ventricular function and normal cardiac index but severe right failure, or in those with right ventricular dysfunction, low cardiac index and only mild right heart failure.

The Cleveland Clinic researchers’ new observational study was designed to characterize patients with right heart failure who underwent isolated tricuspid valve surgery to better identify criteria for candidacy.

Study design and findings

The study included 62 patients who underwent isolated tricuspid valve surgery at Cleveland Clinic from 2007 to 2014. Patients had severe, long-standing tricuspid valve disease and variable degrees of right heart failure and liver dysfunction. Mean age was 57 ± 16 years, and 60% of patients were women. Nearly three-quarters of patients (n = 45) had undergone at least one previous heart operation, including 19 surgeries on the tricuspid valve (10 repairs, nine replacements).

Hospital outcomes included reoperation for valve dysfunction (3.2%), renal failure (4.8%) and one death (1.6%) for a respiratory-related complication.

Cluster analysis was conducted of right heart morphology and function variables from stored echocardiographic images and clinical and hemodynamic data from patient records.

Tricuspid valve variables split patients into two equal clusters: those with functional TR and those with structural TR. Relative to patients with structural TR, those with functional TR had the following characteristics:

  • Older age (62 ± 14 vs. 51 ± 16 years; P = 0.005)
  • Worse right ventricular morphology
  • More severe manifestations of heart failure
  • Greater model for end-stage liver disease with sodium (MELD-Na) scores (12 ±4 vs. 9.1 ± 3.9; P = 0.008)
  • More blood products needed perioperatively
  • Lower 10-year survival following isolated tricuspid valve surgery (48% vs. 73%)


“Despite worse heart failure among patients in the functional TR group, their right ventricular function was similar to that of patients with structural TR,” Dr. Elgharably comments. Cluster analysis also revealed that right ventricular size was more predictive of right heart failure than right ventricular function was.

Patient selection is key

“Patients with severe tricuspid regurgitation and right heart failure have often been considered too high risk and denied surgery as a result,” notes study co-author Patrick Collier, MD, PhD, a cardiologist in Cleveland Clinic’s Section of Cardiovascular Imaging. “This study demonstrates good early surgical outcomes for many of these sick patients and supports referral of such patients by cardiologists. It also shows that careful patient selection is key to better defining of operability and the risks and benefits of tricuspid valve surgery.”

The authors draw two major conclusions from this study:

  • Good early outcomes support expanding selection criteria for tricuspid valve surgery. In this heterogeneous group of patients, even those with functional TR and worse right heart failure survived surgery despite elevated right heart chamber volumes and pressures. Dr. Elgharably notes that patients can be considered low risk if they present with preserved right ventricular function and a normal liver function profile. Right ventricular morphology (i.e., volume) is more predictive of right heart failure than function is.
  • Surgery should be considered earlier for patients with severe functional TR. Patients with functional TR survived isolated tricuspid valve surgery with low morbidity, but their long-term survival was relatively poor compared with patients who had structural TR. Dr. Elgharably points out that most patients with functional TR in the study had previous surgery for left-sided disease and were probably referred late for surgery, and thus had disadvantages of being older and the likelihood of more right ventricular remodeling and unaddressed drivers of disease. “Early referral to centers with right heart failure expertise is warranted for these patients, to avoid poor late outcomes,” he observes.

“Liberalizing criteria should be considered in carefully selected patients,” Dr. Elgharably says, “Findings indicate that patients are likely to have good short- and intermediate-term outcomes, although their long-term prognosis is uncertain.”

He adds that the mortality rate in this study was considerably lower than what is reported in the literature, which typically runs from 8% to 20%. He attributes this in part to careful patient selection, with special attention to ensuring adequacy of right ventricular function and liver function.


Related Articles

completed mitral valve repair
Mitral Valve Re-Repair for Degenerative Disease Found Safe and Durable

Cleveland Clinic series supports re-repair as a favored option regardless of failure timing

illustration of a figure-of-8 stitch for aortic valve repair
Figure-of-8, Hitch-Up Stitch Is Safe and Durable in Bicuspid Aortic Valve Repair

Large retrospective study supports its addition to BAV repair toolbox at expert centers

3D transesophageal echocardiographic images
New Leaflet Modification Technique Curbs LVOT Obstruction Risk in Valve-in-Valve TMVR

Provides option for patients previously deemed anatomically unsuitable

illustration of mitral valve with male/female symbol overlay
Long-Term Outcomes of Mitral Valve Repair for Degenerative MR Worse in Women Than Men

A call for surgical guidelines to adopt sex-specific thresholds of LV size and function

Study Reveals Persistence of Later Surgical Referrals for Severe Degenerative Mitral Regurgitation

While mortality was unaffected, later surgery was associated with more reoperations

23-HVI-4417336 CQD 650×450
Aortic Valve Reimplantation Shows Long-Term Durability in Patients With Connective Tissue Disorders

Many young patients can avoid lifelong anticoagulation with a valve-sparing approach

illustration of mitral valve transcatheter edge-to-edge repair
The Two FDA-Approved M-TEER Systems Are Comparable at 1-Year Follow-Up, CLASP IID Data Show

And substudy reveals good outcomes with PASCAL system in patients with complex mitral valve anatomy