Search IconSearch

Two Serious and Potentially Related Diagnoses Are Often Missed in Younger Women

Differential diagnosis should include vascular diseases


Fibromuscular dysplasia (FMD) should be on every primary care physician’s radar because it can lead to spontaneous coronary artery dissection (SCAD). More than 90 percent of FMD patients are women.


Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy

“FMD is terribly under-recognized and underdiagnosed,” says vascular medicine specialist Heather L. Gornik, MD, Medical Director of the Noninvasive Vascular Laboratory in Cleveland Clinic’s Sydell and Arnold Miller Family Heart & Vascular Institute. “The U.S. Fibromuscular Dysplasia Registry shows about a four-year lag between the time patients present with symptoms and diagnosis.”

FMD: Consider the whole clinical picture

FMD, a nonatherosclerotic arterial disease affecting medium-size vessels, most often involves the renal, carotid and vertebral arteries. FMD may progress to arterial stenosis, beading, aneurysm and, in some cases, dissection.

“Unfortunately, FMD is not high on the differential diagnosis. The presenting symptoms can be easily attributed to other diseases,” says Dr. Gornik.

In addition, symptoms are often addressed individually rather than in the context of a larger clinical picture. The symptoms of FMD include:

  • Early-onset hypertension (40s and 50s)
  • Poorly controlled hypertension
  • Migraine
  • Dizziness
  • Cervical bruit
  • Neck pain
  • Pulsatile tinnitus (swooshing noise in the ears)


The one differentiating symptom of FMD is pulsatile tinnitus, which affects over one third of FMD patients. Pulsatile tinnitus is rare in the general population. However, Dr. Gornik notes that 5.6 percent of patients with FMD are completely asymptomatic.

Suspect SCAD in young women with heart attacks


Coronary angiogram of 35-year-old woman who presented with acute coronary syndrome. There is a type 2 coronary dissection in the mid and distal left anterior descending artery.

SCAD occurs when a tear develops in the innermost layer of a coronary arterial wall or when there is internal bleeding between the wall’s layers, disrupting or blocking blood flow to the heart.
As in FMD, the vast majority of patients who develop SCAD are women. The average age of women who are affected is around 50.

“SCAD is a challenging diagnosis for a number of reasons. While its appearance is very obvious on some coronary angiograms, on others it can mimic plaque or mild coronary artery disease caused by atherosclerosis,” says women’s cardiovascular medicine specialist Esther (Soo Hyun) Kim, MD, MPH, of the Heart & Vascular Institute’s Section of Vascular Medicine and Section of Preventive Cardiology.

She notes that SCAD generally manifests as a heart attack, so when any young woman presents with a heart attack but has few to no traditional risk factors for atherosclerosis, physicians should include SCAD in the differential diagnosis.


Angiograms showing bilateral multifocal FMD of the internal carotid arteries (“string of beads”).

Stents are effective in opening coronary obstruction from atherosclerotic plaque, but they can worsen the dissection in SCAD, triggering more severe obstructions. For this reason, stenting is reserved for severe cases, when SCAD causes persistent pain or when signs indicate the patient is not doing well.

Experts do not yet understand all the underlying causes of SCAD. However, in some cases, SCAD can occur because of arterial weakening due to:

  • Inflammatory disorders such as systemic lupus erythematosus
  • Pregnancy
  • Genetic predisposition, as in the vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome
  • Extreme physical exercise
  • Use of illicit drugs, such as cocaine

SCAD also has been associated with extreme physical or emotional stress.

“While not all SCAD is from FMD, I think we are learning that SCAD is probably a variant presentation of FMD. Some data suggest that if you look at all the arteries
in SCAD patients, 70 percent of the time you will find FMD,” says Dr. Kim.

“However, if you take FMD patients and ask if they have had SCAD, far fewer will cite a history of SCAD. There is clearly a disconnect.”


Research and specialty care

Drs. Gornik and Kim stress the importance of prompt referral for patients with FMD and SCAD.

Medical treatment is usually effective in SCAD. Dr. Kim is enrolling patients in a comprehensive SCAD study that is following patients long-term to gain a better understanding of the natural history.

FMD and SCAD require multidisciplinary management. Since 2008, Cleveland Clinic’s FMD Clinic has offered patients with FMD access to a team of vascular medicine specialists, vascular surgeons, nephrologists, neurologists and neurosurgeons, interventional cardiologists, medical geneticists and other specialists.

To refer patients with FMD or SCAD to Cleveland Clinic, please call 855.REFER.123.


Related Articles

woman giving subcutaneous self-injection in abdomen
Can Enoxaparin Be Used as a Bridge to Warfarin for Outpatients With LVADs?

Cleveland Clinic series supports its feasibility, especially with HeartMate 3

side-by-side procedural images of TAVR and SAVR
Valve-in-Valve TAVR vs. Redo SAVR for a Failed SAVR Bioprosthesis

Questions remain following late mortality signal from a retrospective cohort study

heart with female symbol overlay
Sex Disparities in Cardiac Care: Female Heart Surgeons Act for Change

How two of our surgeons are working for care equity, greater representation in research and practice

operating room during robotic heart surgery
Robotic Mitral Valve Repair: Reflections After 2,400-Plus Cases

Judicious application yields a 99.7% repair rate and 0.04% mortality

nutrition label of product containing xylitol
Another Sugar Substitute, Xylitol, Is Linked to Heightened Cardiovascular Risk

Studies reveal increased cardiac events, enhanced platelet reactivity and thrombotic potential

hypertrophied human heart
A Transaortic Approach to Midventricular and Apical Septal Myectomy

Large single-center series demonstrates safety and efficacy for extending procedure

woman doctor in white coat
Meet Dr. Amanda Vest, New Section Head of Heart Failure and Transplant Cardiology

Eminent clinician-researcher brings special expertise in nutritional interventions for heart failure