Advertisement
Study shows STEMI protocol closes traditional gaps in care metrics and mortality
In an unprecedented study finding, a standardized care protocol has been shown to reduce socioeconomic disparities in care processes and clinical outcomes for a high-acuity, urgent condition like ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI).
Advertisement
Cleveland Clinic is a non-profit academic medical center. Advertising on our site helps support our mission. We do not endorse non-Cleveland Clinic products or services. Policy
Specifically, a comprehensive STEMI protocol adopted by Cleveland Clinic was associated with improved guideline-directed medical therapy (GDMT) across a spectrum of socioeconomic deprivation levels and with reductions in in-hospital mortality that were particularly pronounced in patients with high and moderate levels of socioeconomic deprivation.
“Many prior studies have demonstrated higher mortality after STEMI among patients with lower socioeconomic status, but no previous study has assessed an intervention to mitigate this disparity,” says Umesh Khot, MD, Head of Regional Cardiovascular Medicine at Cleveland Clinic and senior author of the study, which was published in the Journal of the American Heart Association.
Indeed, multiple studies show that use of GDMT before percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), use of revascularization procedures and achievement of recommended door-to-balloon time (D2BT) for STEMI are significantly less common in patients with lower socioeconomic status — and that this results in worse clinical outcomes for these patients, in terms of higher rates of mortality and rehospitalization and lower quality of life.
“When we developed our comprehensive STEMI protocol several years ago, we knew that care disparities related to socioeconomics were an issue both nationally and locally,” explains Dr. Khot. “We wanted to see if we as a health system could improve the care of our most vulnerable patients at their most vulnerable times, such as during a heart attack. We sought to transform the care of these patients by eliminating care variability to ensure the highest level of standardized care for every patient with STEMI.”
Advertisement
The STEMI protocol was implemented by Cleveland Clinic in July 2014 across its Northeast Ohio facilities to minimize variability in care. It did so by way of four key changes and principles (as detailed in a prior Consult QD article):
The current observational cohort study compared care processes and outcomes of consecutive patients with STEMI from January 2011 to July 2019, thereby capturing several years before and after protocol implementation.
To evaluate the impact of socioeconomic status, the researchers used the Area Deprivation Index (ADI), an established summary metric for accurately quantifying socioeconomic position at the neighborhood level. The ADI — which draws on 17 data elements reflecting education, employment, housing and poverty derived from the U.S. Census Bureau and American Community Survey data — is a more granular geographic metric than zip code. “This makes it a better indicator of neighborhood-level socioeconomic position,” notes Dr. Khot. Higher ADI scores denote higher levels of deprivation, corresponding to lower socioeconomic status.
The 1,761 patients with STEMI included in the study were classified by ADI score as residing in low-deprivation neighborhoods (29.0%), moderate-deprivation neighborhoods (40.8%) or high-deprivation neighborhoods (30.2%). The distribution of patients among these groups was statistically similar between the periods before and after STEMI protocol implementation.
Advertisement
Comparative analysis of care metrics and outcomes by patients’ neighborhood deprivation level before and after protocol implementation yielded four major findings:
“These findings support our hypothesis that strategies to minimize STEMI care variability can improve care delivery and reduce mortality in patients at all socioeconomic levels and lessen care disparities,” says co-investigator Grant Reed, MD, MSc, Director of Cleveland Clinic’s Enterprise STEMI Program. He notes that the paradoxical finding that post-protocol D2BT improvements were smallest in the high deprivation group suggests that strategies designed to standardize STEMI care more broadly may eclipse D2BT alone.
Advertisement
“A narrow focus on door-to-balloon-time may exclude some patients from realizing the benefits of STEMI quality improvement programs,” adds co-investigator Amar Krishnaswamy, MD, Section Head of Invasive and Interventional Cardiology at Cleveland Clinic. “Our STEMI protocol’s multicomponent nature is its strength, which has been shown in previous analyses to yield incremental value beyond the benefits achieved from reductions in door-to-balloon time alone.”
An additional recent analysis found the Cleveland Clinic STEMI protocol to be associated with reductions in sex-related disparities in STEMI care and outcomes as well. “Together, these studies suggest that taking a comprehensive, multifaceted approach to standardizing STEMI care has strong potential to level the playing field with regard to STEMI care disparities, whether they stem from a patient’s neighborhood or sex or some other demographic factor,” observes co-investigator Samir Kapadia, MD, Chair of Cardiovascular Medicine at Cleveland Clinic. “We believe this protocol can be a model for other organizations aiming to improve the equity of their care delivery.”
Advertisement
Advertisement
Novel approach outperforms standard of care for post-PVI stenosis and occlusion
Resourceful approaches to the care of patients with microvascular disease and elevated Lp(a)
Support for a TAVR-first approach in patients with concurrent valve and coronary disease
While procedural success rates lag overall, they shine for retrograde crossing
Randomized WATCH-TAVR trial confirms safety of the combined procedures
Lower success rates, more hospital MACE seen with poor-quality distal targets
Black and white patients realize similar gains following adoption of new protocol
Cleveland Clinic experience is applicable to other laboratories